Cattle farmer Roger Troughton found guilty of murder
CATTLE farmer Roger Troughton was yesterday found guilty of murdering his cousin.
Today, the 74-year-old farmer is expected to hear how many years he must spend in jail for killing his mentally-unwell cousin Robin with a spade.
A jury considered its verdict for just four hours yesterday before returning a unanimous guilty verdict following an eight-day trial.
Judge Robert Juckes QC said it had been a difficult case, but the only sentence could be one of life.
He adjourned to consider what the minimum term should be.
Troughton, neatly suited, stood impassively with his arms clasped in front of him as the verdict was announced.
Friends and family in the public gallery, who have been present for most of the trial, showed no reaction.
The jury, of seven women and four men, had been one short since the second day when one of their number fell ill.
Troughton, of Wood Street Farm, Wood Street, Bushley, near Upton-on-Severn, had admitted killing 59-year-old Robin Troughton by hitting him on the head with a fencing spade on Mother's Day last year.
But he denied murder, admitting manslaughter, saying he had acted in self-defence.
He claimed that when he went to the home belonging to Robin Troughton's mother, at Paynes Place in Stokes Lane, Bushley, his cousin came at him with a pair of metal tree-loppers.
It was when he was jabbed in the chest that he struck out.
He then lost control and hit Robin again.
He told the court he did not realise how badly Robin had been hurt, arguing that he thought Robin would simply get up and go home.
Instead, Robin's brother Nigel, who is also known as Tim, noticed Robin was covered in blood three hours later.
Robin was taken to hospital, but never regained consciousness. He died 19 days later.
The court heard that Robin, of The Cowshed, The Ramplings, Longdon, near Tewkesbury, had a history of unruly behaviour.
Only the day before his death, he had taken part in trashing the home of his 86-year-old mother, who was away having respite care.
Judge Robert Juckes QC has described it as a "tragic" case involving a family and friends.
He will hear submissions by defence barrister Rex Tedd QC on the length of sentence for an elderly man before he passes sentence.
BACKGROUND - PROFILE OF ROBIN TROUGHTON
TRAGIC is an often over-used word in the English language but, sadly, it perfectly sums up Robin Troughton’s life and the terrible end to it.
His early years suggested so much promise because he was an exceptionally intelligent person, showing a brilliance in maths at school and moving on to gain an upper second class degree in agriculture at Reading University.
But, as sometimes happens when people are unusually bright, there was another side to him, too.
There were times when the quirky side of his character descended into mental illness.
It first began to affect his life two years into his time at university and was so severe that he had to take a year out from his studies for treatment and rehabilitation.
At various times throughout his life, it would return to haunt him and make him difficult to be around. Sometimes he would go for long periods of good mental health, but then his demons would return and plunge him into such turmoil that he would have to seek professional help.
One villager from Bushley, where his family moved to from Tredington in the early 1970s, said: “Just a week before he died, he was very dishevelled. He wasn’t sure where he was.
“He was treated at Cheltenham and was on medication, but when he was ill he was never aggressive, just odd. He was eccentric and didn’t really make sense.”
The villager, who did not want to be named, said: “The problem with Robin was that you couldn’t reason with him. He was too far gone.”
She added that there was a great feeling of sadness among locals that his illness had caused him so much suffering.
She said: “He didn’t deserve to have his life ended like that.”
But the harsh reality of his health issue was that it prevented him from having a long-lasting career in farming.
During the times when he was having problems, he would obtain help and support from the adult opportunity centre in Tewkesbury.
As part of his recovery programme, he did a spell of shelf-stacking at Tesco but, not surprisingly, found it dull and well below his intellectual ability.
He did enjoy talking to customers, though, because he was always a people person and there was nothing he liked better than to chat to anyone and everyone.
Robin loved smoking a pipe and although he never married, he shared his home with a succession of three cats – all rescued by Cats Protection. Other interests included photography, music and cricket.
But perhaps most important to him was his Christian faith.
He regularly went to church in and around Tewkesbury and loved talking about the Bible.
And it would be harsh not to mention some of the other aspects of Robin’s nature – his energy, enthusiasm, quirky sense of humour and generosity.









8 Comments
by Chris2308
Friday, February 10 2012, 10:47AM
“Msevern, perfectly correct but he can apply for parole at any time on compassionate grounds and at 80 years old he's very likely to get it.”
by Msevern
Thursday, February 09 2012, 8:09PM
“Chris, with "Life" sentences the recommendation of the Judge means that is the term that must be served before parole can be considered. In other words, if he is sentenced to 10 years he will serve 10 years and then some more while parole is considered. If he is deemed safe to go back into society (this is generally only after he has admitted his guilt) then and only then will a release plan be put in place that will see a gradual release through lower grades of prison, to open prison, with working in the community and then release into a hostel. he will forever be on "Life Licence" meaning that if his behaviour gives cause for concern his probation officer can recall him to prison without notice and without a future release date.”
by Chris2308
Thursday, February 09 2012, 2:56PM
“That's roughly how I thought it went down. Obviously there was some kind of argument but there's no evidence of any attack by the victim at all. Whacking somebody over the head with a shovel is a sure way to end the argument but far from reasonable force against an unarmed individual in any circumstance.
Leaving Robin on the floor for 3 hours without offering any assistance whatsoever marks this killer as someone who should never be released. Unfortunately, because of his age he probably will be. Given that Robin lived for another 19 days, it's a decent chance that with immediate triage, he may have survived. I feel for Robin because he must have led a desperately miserable life and for it to end like this makes me as angry as hell. It doesn't matter how much of an embarrassment he may have been, nor does it matter that he may have been 'difficult'. He was family.”
by mattrymer
Thursday, February 09 2012, 2:46PM
“Roger is my Godfather and Robin my elder Brother's. I have to say, Robin was always the Better of the two because Roger always preferred his Cows! Robin felt very proud of being a Godfather. We - the Rymer family - are distraught. Roger was and is an upstanding, solid dedicated farmer and genuine Soul. A stalwart. A week before that confrontation, Robin turned up at our elderly parents late at night and they felt a bit threatened. But they have known him for so many years. They let it go. Mental illness is so difficult to deal with. Allow this Family - this Proud Family - to grieve in peace.”
by Mummy_Hare
Thursday, February 09 2012, 2:08PM
“Chris, These tree loppers were brand new and found in Robins car. So how did he put them back if he was semi conscious?
Robin was no way a violent man. He often said he thought his family wanted him out of the picture because they were ashamed of him. Unfortunately his words turned out to be prophetic.”
by Chris2308
Thursday, February 09 2012, 12:07PM
“Roger Troughton was perfectly entitled to defend himself by whatever means if attacked with a weapon. The reason why this is a murder instead of manslaughter is that;
"He then lost control and hit Robin again". The second swing was pre-meditated and unnecessary to defend and therefore was an attack.
It does read though as if the victim was an embarrassment to his family and nothing is said of what caused Robin to apparently become violent in the first place, if that's true at all which I doubt that it is. In any event, if Roger was jabbed in the chest with a "pair of metal tree-loppers", you'd expect there to be marks from it and I haven't read anything about that.
Given Roger Troughton's age I reckon the judge will give him a minimum of 10 years which means he'll be out in 5.”
by Mummy_Hare
Thursday, February 09 2012, 8:32AM
“I totally agree Missy. Robin didn't have a violent nature, far from it, if anything he was too loving. Glad the Jury saw through Rogers deceipt. Now. How about rearresting Tim, for neglect at least. Also the Crisis team should be held accountable for their lack of action.
RIP Robin, much love, Helen & Daisy. xxxxx”
by MissyMadDog
Thursday, February 09 2012, 8:00AM
“Robin was murdered because he had a mental illness, no other reason for it. His family failed to accept or even acknowledge his illness and just viewed him as a troublesome burden.
Robin was a gentleman who'd battled with mental illness most of his life. He didn't deserve this.”