Dangerous dust is spreading over Gloucestershire village from waste dump

Trusted article source icon
Friday, June 18, 2010
Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

This is Gloucestershire

PEOPLE in Bishop's Cleeve could be breathing in dangerous dust from a hazardous waste site, according to new studies.

Damning reports show clear evidence of dust particles with the potential to cause asthma and respiratory problems lying around Wingmoor Farm.

Grundon Waste Management, which operates the site, has previously maintained all dust is contained within its boundaries.

It is applying to continue dumping hazardous material at the site for another 20 years.

However, two new studies carried out in the wake of the application have recorded levels of dust which campaign groups claim could be harmful.

Barbara Farmer, trustee of campaign group Safety in Waste and Rubbish Disposal, claims the studies "show beyond doubt" hazardous dust is escaping.

She said: "This has been denied for years by both Grundon and the Environment Agency.

"If this is what happens when the site is operating normally, what would happen if there were an accident?

"No one can predict the long-term impact of this additional chemical burden on our communities."

However, a spokeswoman for Grundon played down any health risks at the site.

She said: "Grundon has been carrying out dust sampling and monitoring on Wingmoor Farm for at least 12 years. This includes regular health checks on employees. All of the results indicate there are no risks to health or the environment from the site operations."

Health bosses in the county are unsure if living near the site is harmful to public health, with several studies still investigating the matter.

A study commissioned by the Environment Agency measured dust levels at eight sites within 250m of Wingmoor in 2008.

It found one reading "strongly associated" with dust and others where potentially hazardous dust was present.

The other study was carried out by scientist Dr Andrew Tubb, of Greenfield Science Ltd, who was commissioned by the Sward campaign group.

Dr Tubb said there was no doubt toxic dust, containing carbon, fly ash and heavy metals, was escaping.

He said: "The release of this material into the wider environment may be harmful to humans."

Concerned residents in Bishop's Cleeve attended a meeting organised by campaigners from Sward this week.

The 100-stong audience saw dramatic pictures and video footage of dust clouds blowing across Stoke Road towards homes and farmland.

Mother-of-two Jane Donne, who lives close to Wingmoor Farm, was horrified by what she heard.

She said: "They are running that operation and we are all in their hands.

"It is scary especially having two young children and not knowing what the possible health risks are."

Jane, who lives in Acacia Park, regularly finds dust on the garden furniture and windows.

"We have always had our suspicions about the dust, but now it has been confirmed. The pictures were awful."

Tewkesbury borough councillor Phil Taylor, who attended the Sward meeting, said: "It scared the bejesus out of me. Both reports by Sward's expert and the Environment Agency's show the dust is found 250m away.

"There are a lot of houses built within that distance. This has destroyed all of Grundon's credibility, in my view."

Ceri Jones, county councillor for Bishop's Cleeve, said the evidence was "overwhelming".

"I remember meetings where Grundon were quite clear the dust does not escape from the site. Here is the stark evidence which proves otherwise."

A decision on Grundon's application for 20 more years of operation at Wingmoor is due later this year.

OPINION, P8

20
Tweet this article
Report

20 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Kay Powell, Robinswood

    Sunday, June 20 2010, 5:59PM

    “Venk Shenoi may trust the Environment Agency. I don't.”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Phil, Cheltenham

    Friday, June 18 2010, 7:01PM

    “Matt, to solve a problem the first step is to define it. That was my constructive offering (admittedly on a wider but topical scale). Apologises if it offended!”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Joe K, Barton & Tredworth

    Friday, June 18 2010, 5:12PM

    “The headline is not justified by the story, and it doesn't surprise me that the study which supports Sward's position is the one *they* commissioned. Funny how that works, not.

    Venk Shenoi has hit the nail on the head, that kind of dust release should not be happening and if it did, it should be investigated. That means that Sward, or whoever took the picture will have to say when it was taken (I guess they reported it at the time, which should help to pin it down).

    I wouldn't be at all surprised if Grundon were evasive, though. I get that all the time, from various organisations. Was that business with the questionnaire ever sorted out? If I recall correctly, a whole bunch of them were dumped in a ditch, instead of being distributed to residents...”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Matt, Cheltenham

    Friday, June 18 2010, 4:14PM

    “Phil, Cheltenham, I suggest you get out a dictionary and look up the definition of "constructive".”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Venk Shenoi, Blaisdon Glos

    Friday, June 18 2010, 3:20PM

    “Regardless of the toxiciy issue which one assumes the Envirinment Agency is monitoring, spreading any material which has potential to generate fugitive dust requires certain basic measures to be put in place. One of these being to have a sprinkler system to suppress dust being carried away.

    It is usual practice in the industry for any ash to be conditioned with a small amount of water to prevent the material from being carried out to the atmosphere during tramsport and loading and unloading operations.

    It is for the local authority to monitor this and take steps if the site operator is not complying.

    The picture of the two lorries dumping the stuff with dust rising up does not make sense.”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Actionman, Cheltenham

    Friday, June 18 2010, 2:08PM

    “The answer is in the residents hands. The only way you will get any action from Tewkesbury BC is to get together and give one months notice that Council Tax Direct Debits will be cancelled until an independent outside investigation is carried out.
    IT IS THE ONLY WAY”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Paul, Cheltenham

    Friday, June 18 2010, 1:49PM

    “Phil, I do get it.”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Liz, Woodmancote

    Friday, June 18 2010, 1:20PM

    “Grundons had a meeting 5 years ago which I attended and asked one of the emlpoyees how often the dust was analysed expecting an answer of every week or month. His answer was evasive and I got the impression it was either never or very occasional. It seems the former is nearer the truth.It's hard to believe that it's taken so many years for this test to be done despite the anxiety of many local inhabitants who suffer the dust and the smells from the plant.”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Colin, Bishops Cleeve

    Friday, June 18 2010, 12:53PM

    “The picture says it all. The prevailing wind is from the SW and as the tip has developed towards the east, housing has developed towards the Northwest (including plans for Clevelands) this means more of the population of Cleeve is subjected to the dust from Wingmoor. Also I thought this was a landfill site. Today it looks more like a landhill site as we see the sunset behind the tip instead of what used to be the Malvern hills.”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Doug, Tewkesbury

    Friday, June 18 2010, 12:04PM

    “I lived in Ashlea Meadow for 13 years, and my asthma COPD changed from an inconvenience in summer to 7 day a week medication regime. Even the astma nurse at the doctors confirmed the cases in Cleeve were above the levels of other areas. Moving towards Tewkesbury has improved my condition.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters