Mary Portas review: Gloucester needs big names not pound shops
MOVES to revitalise the high street have been embraced by shoppers and traders in Gloucester.
Retail queen Mary Portas has drawn up a 28-point plan to save bedraggled city centres - and now calls are being made for the advice to be taken on board here.
-

NO LIFE? Northgate Street in Gloucester yesterday. Top from left; Gillian Part, Diane Young, Carol Miller and Gordon Williams. Top right: 'Queen of Shops' Mary Portas.
Disgruntled shoppers in Gloucester's gated streets yesterday said changes could not come soon enough.
At the moment 33 shops in the city are empty, 11 per cent of the total.
That compares well to the national average of 14.5 per cent, but is well below other county areas such as Cirencester and the Cotswolds, both at six per cent.
Carol Miller, 67, from Linden, said: "There's so many shops in Gloucester closing down and you get lots of the same kind of shops here, all these pound shops.
"The city centre needs more big names, we need a TK Maxx here."
Diane Young, 46, from Longlevens, said: "I don't Gloucester is up to scratch.
"It's missing any major shops, it needs a Next and things like that. You can't always get you want in the city centre so I think it does need some help."
Gordon Williams, 82, of London Road, said: "I definitely back what this report has said about tax in supermarket car parks, that needs to be addressed.
"The city centre isn't what it used to be, there's no life to it."
Gillian Part, 75, from Haresfield, said: "I think it's struggling because people have not got any money.
"If rents were lowered maybe more shops could open up."
Leader of Gloucester City Council, Councillor Paul James (Con, Longlevens) said the report provided food for thought but that Gloucester's has a bright future.
"In some way we have already got a team managing the city centre, we have regular stakeholder meetings to see what's happening there and what needs to happen," he said.
"There's definitely still a place for the high street today but you have to make it an attractive place for people to visit and given them more to do than just shop.
"I think we're doing that, we have all our historic buildings that people can explore but we do recognise there is work to be done."
Other community leaders echoed that view.
Barry Leach, secretary of Gloucester City Centre Community Partnership, added: "We need to look at the shops that have been empty for a long time and need to be a bit radical with them.
"Gloucester may not be among the high-flying city centres at the moment, but it's not among the worse."
Ivan Taylor, who owns Truscott Jewellers and represents traders in the Westgate Quarter, said: "I think any input that tries to look at city centres has got to be welcome.
"Gloucester is getting its fair share of business coming in from outside at the moment but there are a lot of shops empty too.
"We've got to be saying to customers 'yes we can' when it comes to customer service.
"That's how businesses will survive in the future, I think."
Clare Gerbrands, organiser of Gloucester and Stroud’s Farmers’ Markets gives her reaction to the Portas review:
FINALLY, someone has come along who understands the challenges facing high street retail in the current social and economic climate.
Whilst I applaud Mary Portas in opening the debate, and highlighting issues such as the lack of tax on supermarket car parks, I am hesitant to agree with her report whole-heartedly.
It is more regulation of market stalls which will bring shoppers into town centres, not less. I also believe a complete turnaround by local authorities, who have come to view markets as an income stream rather than as a community investment, would help markets to thrive more by freeing up capital for investment in equipment and special events. I see competitive tendering as favouring large market operators over community based market organisations, with an inevitable loss of identity for the events and their customers.
The outstanding success of our farmers markets, which are nationally recognised, has been built upon the triangle of regulation, community and business which I first used as a model when I started Made in Stroud in 1990. It is precisely by working with local environmental health and trading standards officials, all of whom assisted in writing my Safe Food Policy for Farmers Market Stallholders.
The policy has been adopted as a national standard, and we have created a market place for top quality local producers, with food safety standards at our market above the legal minimal requirements.
All our stallholders are inspected and insured, so customers can be assured they are buying only the highest quality food and drink from genuinely local producers.
I'd welcome the opportunity to invite Mary Portas to our market in Stroud to discuss how markets can regenerate town centres, build community and create a solid economic foundation during times of crisis. I'm sure we have a lot of common ground and a lot of experience to share and I am a great admirer of her work.







24 Comments
View all
by nicknike
Sunday, December 18 2011, 10:12PM
“My advice, get out. After 55 years in Gloucester, we escaped. It's finished as a city. Too many well paid manufacturing jobs have been lost, and the council management has been appalling for more than 30 years.
Sorry, Gloucester is just a dump now.”
by thomasjamesl
Sunday, December 18 2011, 10:46AM
“Oh and let's get that new cinema in the docks. My kid loves the cinema but not the one in Gloucester, but we would go to a new one.
That surely has to be a priority for the Council and planners.”
by thomasjamesl
Sunday, December 18 2011, 10:43AM
“There are some important points mentioned
Make the Town Centre safe and clean
Large retailers are not the sole answer, sometimes you need to start afresh with new ideas, more leisure, more services, new retailers with something different.
Manage the landlords, it's not about pound shops but choice and variety,
Maximise on what we have already and add events, link it all together make it bigger, the catherdral, all the other destinations like the docks, the town centre, the quays, the supermarkets, the retail parks. Don't fragment go for aggregation and make the whole more attractive.”
by thomasjamesl
Sunday, December 18 2011, 10:01AM
“The Portas report appeared to show some forward thinking around bringing life and social activity back to the High Street. For instance bring services such as doctors drop in surgeries and more leisure where retailers would start to cluster. The High Street can not rely on retailers, they are businesses and will move to where the most sustainable future opportunities exist. The High Street needs to make itself more intimate and enjoyable rather than focus on just retail, it's needs a more holistic management. Encourage landlords to look for something different and perhaps give them incentives to do so.
Also to compare the Quays or retail parks with the City Centre is an anathema. Retail parks provider huge boxes for the retailers which High Street can't provide. The Quays retailers are outlet retailers. This means they are from a different market, they focus on older but still desirable stock. They don't sell the same stuff as the High Street retailer. So a Next on the High Street is not selling the same stuff as Next Clearance.
I still believe new destinations such as the Quays will deliver greater football to the whole City from the tourism and people travelling from wider afield to come to the docks and do a bit of shopping in the Quays or the High Street. I have seen throngs of people walking between the Quays and the Centre of Town.”
by tomspam
Friday, December 16 2011, 9:51PM
“Michael, actually I don't think they would. Sure you might get fewer loss-leader pricings in store but I don't think any supermarket would like to explain to upper management why they introduced parking charges and turned away customers!”
by Michael_AH
Friday, December 16 2011, 9:10PM
“If Cameron & Clegg's Government start taxing supermarket car parks, like this Mary person suggests, how long would it be before the supermarkets would start charging for parking?”
by tomspam
Friday, December 16 2011, 8:29PM
“Jas36, thanks for the info. Genuinely enlightening. I share your belief that the Quays development is a positive thing for Gloucester. It just seems that the whole concept of bringing Mary P into advise along traditional lines seems a little pointless when investment (public/ private is split across two hubs in the town. Perhaps some non-traditional thinking about the future of the town centre is needed?”
by camerony2k
Friday, December 16 2011, 5:30PM
“Stop moaning about the City Centre the shops are too small for the big retailers. 10 years ago there was going to be the blackfrias development which would have created a shopping centre from Mc Donalds to Commerical Road but as BT wouldn`t sell their car park it didnt happen. The Quays was funded by private money it has NOTHING to do with the CITY COUNCIL..
Lets now wait for the Kings Quarter Development.
Also City Centres dont have widespread Free Parking because your get all the workers parking there and the shoppers wont have anywhere to park then who will be moaning.”
by echoing
Friday, December 16 2011, 3:17PM
“Harrods, Fortnum Mason and Mappin Webb could provide interesting window displays for shoppers to see on their way to the pound shops they can afford to use.”
by SandraPee
Friday, December 16 2011, 12:45PM
“Maybe potential shop owners in the city centre should have the same ''carrots'' offered to them , as has been offered to Quay's shops ?!”