PCC candidate Rupi Dhanda tweets over Gloucestershire badger cull
THE Labour candidate to become Gloucestershire's first Police Commisioner has sparked controversy by saying she would use her power to stop the badger cull if elected.
Rupi Dhanda told followers on Twitter that if she gets the job, she would not allow officers to attend the cull.
-

Rupi Dhanda
The tweet said: "If I am elected as PCC (Police and Crime Commissioner) my officers will not oversee a badger cull, hence no cull. Full stop."
But critics said it showed Mrs Dhanda has not grasped what the role entails.
Business Cards From Only £10.95 Delivered www.myprint-247.co.uk
View detailsOur heavyweight cards have FREE UV silk coating, FREE next day delivery & VAT included. Choose from 1000's of pre-designed templates or upload your own artwork. Orders dispatched within 24hrs.
Terms: Visit our site for more products: Business Cards, Compliment Slips, Letterheads, Leaflets, Postcards, Posters & much more. All items are free next day delivery. www.myprint-247.co.uk
Contact: 01858 468192
Valid until: Friday, May 31 2013
One of her rivals at next month's election, retired county police superintendent Martin Surl standing as an independent, said: "If she intends to bring pressure on the Chief Constable not to police the cull, that is very dangerous.
"The police frequently have to stand between opposing groups and often get abuse from both sides.
"They have their own views but police without fear or favour – that's why it's called the thin blue line."
Mrs Dhanda, wife of the city's ex-Labour MP Parmjit Dhanda, has opposed the cull for reasons of animal cruelty, pressure on police and because she does not believe it is the best method for preventing bovine TB.
Her tweet prompted several replies, including one from Sam Chapman, who runs the Top of the Cops website, who wrote: "Rupi, have you read the policing protocol? This is clearly an operational matter and it would be unlawful for a PCC to interfere."
Christopher E Wright said: "That is surely an operational decision and outside PCC remit... by a very long way."
But tweeter Jo Ward said: "I'm praying that you win then."
Mrs Dhanda declined to comment, but her tweet has been removed. A police spokesman said it would not be appropriate to comment.




Comments
by GlosYap2
Tuesday, October 23 2012, 2:11PM
“Dear people of Gloucestershire, before you vote...
If you want a position of authority to be created, at great taxpayer expense, just to have that person flipflopping all over the place and chasing votes rather than getting down to the business of doing the job the police are supposed to then by all means vote. Politics in policing doesnt work and at this time of so-called austerity the last thing our public money should be spent on is yet more politicians and their expenses books!!!
Send a message in the easiest way possible - boycott the vote! If enough people do so then maybe those in Whitehall will understand that we have had enough of the creeping political interference in every aspect of our lives...”
by gallopingbear
Tuesday, October 23 2012, 1:24PM
“The badger woman pulled out, and this woman saw an opportunity to nab those votes....
fail.”
by IsitJimKerr
Tuesday, October 23 2012, 10:55AM
“Fantastic, no cull, at least for a while.
So no need to vote for a PCC.”
by Spud0
Sunday, October 21 2012, 11:48AM
“This is an example of the consequences of the politicisation of the Police when priorities are set by elected officials (by probably a very small minority of the population), their decisions may or may not always be to your liking but Government policies could be thwarted or rights to protest could be curtailed so we are likely to see an increase in polictical interference and conflict with the police.
The badger cull is politically motivated and has no scientific basis, however bringing the police into the controversy is a mistake as they have to protect both the pro-cull farmers and the anti-cull groups rights to protest, which will be difficult if the Police Commisioner's imposing their political will into policing.
I won't be voting for Gloucestershire's Police Commisioner, politics and policing should be kept as far apart as possible.”
by GlosYap2
Sunday, October 21 2012, 10:09AM
“Voting for any individual PCC will not "protect badgers". The PCC will have no power to make that decision. To all those pro-animal rights ppl here who are saying they will vote for her because of this - dont waste your vote or get drawn into this BS political rubbish revolving around PCCs - having an elected Police Commissioner will be the biggest waste of taxoayer cash!!!”
by justjude
Sunday, October 21 2012, 1:30AM
“good enough for me now voting for Dhanda, the mass slaughter of one of our few remaining wild animals is a disgrace. If a local supermarket will now stop stocking gloucestershire beef/dairy products i will shop there”
by tommadeit
Saturday, October 20 2012, 7:14PM
“Brilliant stopping the extinction of badgers and Dhandas at the same time - good luck Rupi”
by Emwye
Saturday, October 20 2012, 7:03PM
“To Tim Messenger and everone else who thinks the badger cull couldl reduce their tax bill
Article in the telegraph: The cost of culling badgers to the taxpayer far exeeds any cost saving according to Govt Advisor and University of Exeter Prof. Basically every tax payer will be poorer if badgers are killed.
http://tinyurl.com/8sg7xqx
ps dont shoot the messenger!”
by GlosCityRes
Saturday, October 20 2012, 6:30PM
“Thank god, a candidate with a bit of backbone to speak out. Its pointless to make too much out of what is and is not in the remit of PCC as it is a brand new role and no doubt will evolve as time goes on, whats important is that we get someone in the post who wants to look after the Police as well as the interest of the public!
The only other person who seems to have their own voice is that independent bloke, though I'm not sure having an ex copper is wise, will it be too much of the "old boys club"?”
by Emwye
Saturday, October 20 2012, 3:38PM
“Well if any comsolation I've had comment removed then a comment simply about my comment being removed has also been removed! So if youre reading this its a miracle”