Shoddy work led to lethal boiler blast, inquest told

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, October 30, 2008
Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

This is Gloucestershire

A boiler which exploded and killed a grandmother was de- commissioned in a "slipshod fashion" by a poorly qualified plumber, an inquest heard yesterday.

Christine Goodall, 65, died of multiple injuries when the cast iron boiler behind the fireplace in her lounge burst, showering the room with shrapnel and burning logs.

Since the explosion, Severn Vale Housing Association has visited about 1,700 homes to make sure residents are safe.

Mrs Goodall, a retired shop assistant, was told the open fire in her home at Twyning was safe to use when the boiler was put out of service in 1999. After lighting the fire on November 11 last year for the first time since the boiler was put out of service, the boiler heated up, the inquest heard.

Because it had not been fitted with a venting valve, the residual water expanded to bursting point.

Before recording a narrative verdict, Gloucestershire coroner Alan Crickmore said inadequate guidelines provided by Severn Vale, and heating engineer Matthew Lee's lack of understanding, left Mrs Goodall at risk.

Summing up the evidence, he said: "The back boiler was decommissioned by Matthew Lee in 1999, for a contract from Severn Vale Housing.

"While there's no evidence Severn Vale had cause to criticise Mr Lee's work, there's equally no evidence to suggest his work was inspected.

"It seems to me Mr Lee carried out his work in relation to the decommissioning in a slipshod fashion and this, coupled with Mr Lee's lack of understanding of the requirements, led to Mrs Goodall being left in danger."

Earlier in the inquest Mrs Goodall's son Mark Goodall broke down in tears as he recalled the day of his mother's death. He said: "I was shocked at the state of the place. It was totally unexpected. I was happy the boiler was safe – from what my mum was told."

Laurence Aston, contracts manager at Severn Vale Housing Association, told the inquest at Shire Hall, Gloucester, he was pleased with work completed in the past by M & T Plumbing.

He said he understood the work completed at Mrs Goodall's home was not inspected, but this was not unusual as only a selection of homes were visited.

Mrs Goodall had lived in Twyning for 48 years and worked in the Village Stores for 30 years before retiring in February 2007. Her husband Gordon died in 1990 and some years afterwards she found companionship with a new partner Bill, who died died five years ago.

She left three sons, Kevin, 48, Guy, 43, and Mark, 40, and three grandchildren, Aimee, Sebastian, Rory and Laura.

Mark, from Ashchurch, said: "Everyone in the village knew her." His wife Alison added there was no point in criticising the plumber. She said: "He's got enough on his plate. The strongest thing that can come out of this is that people, even in private houses, should get their back boiler drilled or taken out by a competent plumber."

A Severn Vale spokesman said it offered profound sympathy to Mrs Goodall's family: "As a result we have visited around 1,700 of our homes in order to make sure our residents are safe. Customers who may still be unsure whether they have a back boiler, or have a back boiler and are unsure if it is safe, should call us on 01684 272727."

23
Tweet this article
Report

23 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Norman Miles, Chengdu,China

    Friday, October 31 2008, 8:09AM

    “Do they not have any guide lines to follow,I did when working on aircraft,and I was very careful as any thing missed or mistakes made could have led to a charge of criminal negligence.N.S.Miles”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Peter, Cheltenham

    Friday, October 31 2008, 7:56AM

    “I have read these comments and most are unhelpful. Forget safety valves on a decommisioned back boiler.DRILL HOLES. Any so called plumber who does not know the result of water in a sealed heat exchanger should go back to school, Any body with half a brain should know.You do not need to be brain of Britain.”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by John Brooks, Croydon

    Friday, October 31 2008, 12:55AM

    “I simply can't understand the logic in fitting any sort of valve on a REDUNDANT back boiler! The best solution, surely, is first to make sure it's properly drained (if it's dry there's NO risk of any steam explosion) and DRILL several holes into the heat exchanger so it's no longer a boiler! Any sort of mechanical valve is just an invitation to later mechanical failure!”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by steve, Gloucester

    Thursday, October 30 2008, 9:14PM

    “Well done neil at least you had the decency to say sorry”

  • Profile image for This is Gloucestershire

    by Big Al, Cheltenham

    Thursday, October 30 2008, 8:07PM

    “I note a nasty number of comments on this page,are they realy needed?, yes there are some shoddy workers, that puts peoples lives at risk. over the years i have employed about four different local, so called reputable companies to look after my gas system,to which i have had one company blaming another for failures,bottom line it was poor workmanship, how can these poeple get a corgie registration. I have since last year found a reliable company but i have to send to Gloucester for them.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters